There’s More Space in Your Life Than You Think

The confinement we feel every day comes from a way of seeing that we can learn to change, writes Tarthang Tulku in this excerpt from the 50th-anniversary edition of his classic book Time, Space, and Knowledge: A New Vision of Reality, just released by Dharma Publishing.

By Tarthang Tulku Rinpoche

Buddhadharma

Back to Buddhadharma Home

Whatever we do, wherever we go, whatever happens on this crowded surface of interactions constituting our world, there is also the sky. The sky is perhaps the simplest example of space, but it is a very important symbol as well. No matter how tangled, crowded, and intense our activities might be, the sky is present too, directly above everything.

The sky is a familiar — we might even say a “local” — representative of space, and as such, partakes of our typical concern with boundaries. Though it can be contemplated in its vastness, openness, and depth, even the sky is related to as a boundary — an enclosing spherical surface. However, no sooner do we relate to it in this way than we are reminded, in that very act, of the even larger, more open spaces of solar system, galaxy, and universe. Inside or beneath the opacities and hard surfaces that define us and our encounters, there is also space. Intangible, immeasurable psychological spaces constitute the person whose body we see as definite and localized.

Macroscopic and microscopic spaces are within every body or object. And all spaces, in turn, seem to be amenable to the presence of objects. Thoughts are “within” mind-spaces. Organs, molecules, atoms, and subatomic particles, as well as planets, stars, and galaxies, are all moving in their spaces.

Our perceptions of various spaces and “things” reflect different levels and types of analysis. For any given level of analysis, there is the appearance of “objects” only because a very precise “focal setting” or perspective is maintained. The basic, absolute, or opaque character that some things have for us is due to our unwillingness to change this “focal setting” point of view, or to our assumption that it cannot be done.

At one time, no one even considered penetrating to the “inside” of the atom. But then it was tried, people found enormous spaces and energies there, as well as a new and pervasive understanding of the macroscopic world. New times involve new possibilities, and our present time may allow us to discover new spaces in areas where no one has ever thought to look. For example, it may be possible to discover a kind of space in some intimate connection with each thought, each sensation, each surface and in each conceptual category that constitutes our lived world. The availability of such discoveries is entirely a matter of the particular “focal setting” or perspective we use.

What we perceive as solid or opaque “things,” produced by a given “setting,” define by contrast what we perceive as the “space” of that level. So, by attending only to the apparently solid things and the contrasting space resulting from one particular “setting,” we cannot discover the actual nature of either “existence” or “appearance.”

Throughout history, we have been maintaining a fixed and limiting “focal setting” without even being aware of doing so. Yet, although our familiar world seems to depend upon this “setting”, if we become able to change the “setting”, fantastic new knowledge and appreciation of life can be gained.

The idea of discovering new spaces may seem at first to be a purely abstract, intellectual endeavor. But in fact it is rooted in the deeply felt need to find an alternative to the sense of restriction and confinement that each of us experiences in our daily lives. This feeling of lack of space, whether on a personal psychological level or an interpersonal, sociological level, has led to experience of confusion, conflict, imbalance, and general negativity within modern society. We find ourselves setting up strict definitions of territorial boundaries, either as individuals or as larger groups or nations; then great amounts of our energies are utilized in protecting and defending these boundaries. But if we can begin to open our perspective and discover new dimensions of space within our immediate experiences, the anxiety and frustration that results from our sense of limitation will automatically be lessened; and we can increase our ability to relate sensitively and effectively to ourselves, to others, and to our environment.

If we employ new “focal settings” and see the way they work, we can come to an overall understanding that is itself a kind of space. Moreover, this “understanding,” which is also a “space,” explains, expresses, and is everything. Though it may seem to go against an ordinary world view, an understanding — or vision — can itself be the revealing basis of all reality. Even attention to our ordinary space may help to expose this comprehensive “space” vision as being based on what could be called Great Space.

Space is not only above and beyond us; space is also within us and surrounds us. Objects are never really “frozen solid.” Space, room for activity, is both inside and around all objects, and so they move, even in existing. Where do they come from, where are they, and where do they go? It seems the answer again is “space.” Look around you and contemplate this. Let your perception be drawn out by the associations which are given to the ordinary term “space.”

Finding space is not difficult. But what is space in itself? Though we do not ordinarily ask this question, the answer that would commonly come to mind is perhaps that space is what “makes room” for objects and activities. This simple definition seems somewhat inaccurate, however, for physical space does not “do” anything. Also, perceived space and its contents are interrelated, co-defining, so that the visible space of the situation is not more basic than the objects. So, perhaps there is no “space in itself” — or none that has much positive significance.

However, there is reason to question this conclusion, for, while a narrow focal setting may show objects, a change in setting will reveal space. Moreover, the objects of the initial situation “need space” to exist. And the “seeing of the objects and the space” also occurs in a kind of space. Space is everywhere and quite important in itself, even if some aspects of it cannot be defined in isolation from objects and events.

It is at least fair to say that space on any given level is worthy of consideration, just as ‘things’ are, and that the space aspect is more vast. It encompasses everything we know, and also leads us beyond, beckoning ever beyond. Yet rather than attending to this infinite and transcendent character of space, intellectual energy busies itself with trying to keep up with the infinite wealth of information to be had about objects. Meanwhile space, unlike objects, remains infinite in a way that is untrackable and ungraspable.

At any level of analysis, we can find objects that entice, interest, and preoccupy us; but we also find immeasurably more space. And by contemplating this space we may be able to open up and experience a level of relaxation and satisfaction that we are usually unable to touch through our preoccupation with “things.” However, if we try to “track” this space by itself to any great degree, we may fall into confusion or experience a kind of “blackout.” While space around objects may seem appropriate, necessary, and restful, space within objects may appear a little bewildering. And space considered by itself may appear meaningless, or perhaps even forbidding.

Space by itself is difficult to attend to because our ordinary world view has an implicit preference for tangible “things:” existence, existents, interactions, events, causes and effects. Any explanations that are proposed for “how things are” must ordinarily select something from this picture, with its thing-as-cause orientation. However, it would be helpful to try to reverse this emphasis temporarily and attend more to the significance of the presence of space.

Objects seem to depend on space in many respects, although it is true that objects are not, at least in any common view, subordinate to or caused by their surrounding spaces. But they are in fact mostly space, as a more microscopic view shows. The macro- or microscopic constitutive elements “need” space to “be present” and also turn out to be mostly space.

At a certain point, we may wonder whether our usual emphasis on “objects” and our relative indifference to space is not misguided. Is existence “at bottom” really space? Can space itself be the fundamental nature of existence that we seek elsewhere or simply ignore? We have seen the difficulty in setting ordinary types of space apart either as being independent or as being a fundament of existence. For, perceived space is interrelated with the notion of the perceived object, while physical space partakes of the common sense dichotomy between existence and nonexistence. Objects exist, but physical space is “nothing” — nonexistence. A “nothing” cannot stand on its own in any significant way, nor can it serve as a cause for anything else.

However, even the ordinary notions of space may be fundamental in some ways. This possibility is clear for physical space, since we usually feel that it is ultimate in the sense that it exists even without objects. The reverse of this is not usually thought to be true; that is, objects “depend on” the presence of space. Moreover, even for the case of perceived space, where the perception of space as opposed to “things” is a single process (the two aspects complementing each other), there may be some sort of “space” or openness that is fundamental and necessary for perceptions of presences and absences to occur at all.

The general relationships and contrasts that we ordinarily find to hold between space and “things” can be taken as an interesting and suggestive aspect of our realm as a whole. We can see from them the possibility that our familiar reality is an expression or variation of another, more unified reality, but has unfolded in such a way as to give great significance to dualistic categories. As a consequence, reality has become expressed in terms of “something” and “nothing.” But information pertaining to the higher, more unified order cannot be lost in any ultimate sense. It can only be rearranged or cast in a form that admits of ambiguity. This would mean that both the higher and the lower order perspectives are founded on such ambiguous presentations. One very useful and positive consequence of such ambiguity means even conventional dichotomies themselves preserve, in a symbolic or “inspired” sense, expressions of a higher order with unity, suggesting that space and objects coexist, with space relaxing and allowing us to open up, while constituting an intimidating blankness if we pursue it by itself. The coexistence of space and objects is rendered furthermore suggests that we can change our focal setting and find space where before we saw objects and even objects where we saw space. And again, the relaxing character of space contrasts in an interesting way with the tendency of objects to lure us into endless closed-minded engagements.

When used in a certain way, these considerations need not be merely poetic daydreams. They can be pleasing and accurate symbols of a reality that cannot be shut out, no matter how much it may conform in appearance to conventional customs.

These symbol-laden presentations of our reality can be put to use. If we consider existence with the perception of our “mind’s eye” — tracking it “within and without,” “to and from” — it seems that we have no choice but to consider a kind of space as fundamental. The deeper we investigate, the stronger this tendency becomes. The source and resting point of all existence appears to be space.

We can leave logical analyses aside for the moment and continue to contemplate the comings and goings of things in our “mind’s eye”. It almost seems as if an object that is “here” has appeared from a past condition of empty space, needs that space to be here, and gives way to a future condition of, again, empty space — “nonexistence.” It looks like space is projecting into space — that is all! Even what seems to fill up the space as a present tense, existing object, is also space. So, space is projecting space into space!

Reflect on this picture of all existence and “happening” for a while.


Excerpted from Chapter One of the new, 50th anniversary edition of Time, Space, and Knowledge by Tarthang Tulku, with permission of Dharma Publishing.

Tarthang Tulku Rinpoche

Tarthang Tulku Rinpoche is a teacher in the Nyingma lineage of Tibetan Buddhism and the founder of over twenty organizations preserving and promoting Buddhist wisdom in Asia and the West. He has authored over two dozen books including Gesture of Balance, Time, Space, and Knowledge, Kum Nye Tibetan Yoga, and more.