What the Buddha Discovered Upon Perceiving Dependent Origination

That discovery and his articulation of it is why, argues Randy Rosenthal, the Buddha is the greatest philosopher in human history.

By Randy Rosenthal

Indra’s Net image by David.parrott, Via Wikimedia/Creative Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Indras_Net-01.pngnshot)
Buddhadharma

Back to Buddhadharma Home

Many people who start studying Buddhist philosophy quickly encounter the concept of interconnection, perhaps in the form of Indra’s Net. A web made entirely of jewels, each of which reflects all the others, Indra’s Net is a metaphoric image illustrating the interdependence of everything in the universe: every single thing is dependent on everything else, and each being affects all others. Moreover, it implies that each part of the universe contains the whole of the universe — which you can understand practically as your body being composed of elements released in supernovas that occurred billions of years ago. (You not only contain multitudes, you contain the universe!)

But when the Buddha himself taught interdependence, he taught something else — something subtly more insightful. Indeed, the Buddha referred to his insight into dependent origination as what caused him to become awakened. It was the engine of his enlightenment.

So what is it? What did he discover?

Dependent origination is the twelve-factor causal process of how beings come into one form of existence and pass into another. It’s a series of links that form the chain of becoming. A relational pattern of causation, with a formula expressed as: When this, then that. With the arising of this, comes the arising of that. Just as scientists identified DNA to be the building block of biological life, the Buddha identified the twelve links of dependent origination to be the building blocks of samsara — the cycle of death and rebirth. 

In my opinion, the Buddha’s discovery of dependent origination is why he’s the greatest philosopher in human history.

It began the night of his awakening, when he was still Siddhartha, an unenlightened seeker. And as he was sitting under the bodhi tree, he focused on the problem he was trying to solve: aging, illness, and death. So he wondered, Why does aging, illness, and death arise? What is the condition for it? 

In what he called “a breakthrough of wisdom,” it occurred to him that aging, illness, and death arise because of birth. Like all great discoveries, the realization is so simple it sounds obvious: When birth comes to be, aging, illness, and death are sure to follow. 

Then he wondered, What is the condition of birth? Becoming is the condition for birth, he realized.

And what is the condition for becoming? Clinging. With clinging, becoming arises.

And what is the condition for clinging? Craving. With craving, clinging arises.

And what is the condition for craving? Sensation. With sensation, craving arises.

And what is the condition for sensation? Contact. With the contact of external stimuli, sensation arises.

And what is the condition for contact? The sense bases. When there are the sense bases, contact arises.

And what is the condition for the sense bases? Mind and matter. When there is the mental process and matter—the psychological-physical structure we call the self—the sense bases arise.

And what is the condition for the mental process and matter? Consciousness. When there is consciousness, the mental process and matter arise.

And what is the condition for consciousness?  Fabrication. When there is fabrication, consciousness arises.

And what is the condition for fabrication to arise? Ignorance. When there is ignorance, fabrications arise. 

Ignorance of what? Ignorance of the true nature of the self, the intricate processes of the mind-matter phenomenon.

Like this, the Buddha thought through every step in the process of existence — realizing it’s not a linear unfolding, but a simultaneous co-arising; not a timeline, but a recursive feedback loop. He started from the end (death) and went back to the cause (ignorance). 

And then, to clarify his realization, he went through the same process backward, starting from the cause and going through to the end. 

It begins with ignorance. 

With ignorance of the self and the perceptions that illuminate the true nature of existence — inconstancy, not-self, and suffering — a being engages in fabrication. Thought formations. The activity of constructing experience. 

With fabrication, consciousness arises. The awareness of existence.

With consciousness, mind and matter arise—the bundle of mental processes and material elements, the psychological-physical structure we call the self.

With the mental process and matter, the sense bases arise and begin to function. 

With the sense bases, contact occurs with the external world. 

With contact between the sense bases and external stimuli, sensations arise—pleasant, unpleasant, or neutral sensations. 

Depending on the sensation, craving arises. Craving for more pleasant sensations, or craving for unpleasant sensations to go away. 

This craving intensifies to become clinging. We cling to our pleasures, just as we cling to our views that justify our way of living. We cling to our existence. 

Because of clinging, becoming itself arises—the life continuum.

Because of becoming, being carries on through death and into rebirth, into another form of existence.

With birth comes old age and death, and all the suffering of samsara: sorrow, lamentation, pain, dejection, and misery.

It seems like a pretty dire analysis. Fortunately, the Buddha turns it around yet again, understanding that just as each link in the chain arises from the one before it, each link in the chain ceases with the cessation of the one before it:

With the cessation of ignorance, fabrications cease to arise.

With the cessation of fabrications, consciousness ceases to arise.

With the cessation of consciousness, the mental processes and matter cease to arise.

With the cessation of the mental processes and matter, the sense bases cease to arise.

With the cessation of the sense bases, contact ceases to arise.

With the cessation of contact, sensations ceases to arise.

With the cessation of sensations, craving ceases to arise.

With the cessation of craving, clinging ceases to arise.

With the cessation of clinging, becoming ceases to arise.

With the cessation of becoming, birth ceases to arise.

With the cessation of birth, old age, illness, and death cease to arise.

And like that, one comes out of the cycle of sorrow, lamentation, pain, dejection, and misery. 

With this realization, wisdom arose in him, clear knowledge arose — he became the Awakened One, the Buddha.

Okay, but how? After all, just because someone intellectually understands and accepts that all existence is based on ignorance, it doesn’t mean they suddenly stop being ignorant. And once we have mind and matter and the sense bases, there’s nothing we can do to get rid of them. So it seems like we’re helpless to break this chain of becoming. 

Until the Buddha points out the weak link: the connection between sensation and craving. 

It’s natural for craving to arise after a sensation, but it doesn’t have to. Because if we can observe the sensations of the body with equanimity, with detachment, we can feel the sensations arise and pass away, without generating craving for more of them. Once we stop generating craving, the link is broken, and the entire chain collapses. That’s why the Buddha stated this simple formula: mindfulness immersed in the body is the path to awakening. 

Mindfulness immersed in the body is the path to awakening. 

For those of us not so motivated to reach awakening just yet, mindfulness immersed in the body still provides many benefits in this life. For one thing, we become less reactive. When we’re tired, or cold, or hot, or hungry, we can observe those unpleasant sensations, and not react to them. We can watch them arise, stay for some time, and pass away, maintaining an equanimous demeanor. We’ll be less likely to snap at people, to say and do things we’ll later regret.

True, easier said than done. But even the mere awareness of bodily sensations mitigates their strength. We still may feel unpleasant and become a little crabby, but we can observe those unpleasant sensations and tell ourselves: It’s just cold, it’s just hunger, it’s just pain—it will pass. Eventually, I’ll get warm again, and I’ll eat again, and my pain will diminish. And with that reframing of the situation, our crabbiness goes away.

In this way, an understanding of dependent origination also results in an understanding of impermanence: Everything that arises is subject to passing away. As it arises, so it passes away. 

Another way mindfulness immersed in the body benefits us here and now is that it makes us feel more alive, to be fully embodied. This helps us be better connected with our natural balance, so that we don’t mindlessly over indulge. So that we don’t reach into the bag of chips while we’re still chewing. So that we don’t go for a drink just because we feel a little discomfort. So that we don’t check our phones just because we have a few free moments. It’s not a stretch to say we’re an unhealthy society, with way too many people suffering from all kinds of diseases and conditions caused by overindulgence, by a lack of moderation. Immersing mindfulness in the body is a way to regain balance and health — without having to rely on pills or wearable health-tech devices. 

After all, the body is interconnected too, with every part of the body being interdependent with every other part. Injuries in our knees lead to problems in our back. Deficiencies in our diet lead to problems in our immune system. A lack of sleep can cause dysfunction in our lymphatic system. And a stressed-out mind can create problems in our circulatory system, respiratory system, and everywhere else. 

Our mind-body phenomenon is a vast web of interconnected channels, with every single thing affecting every thing else.  

Randy Rosenthal

Randy Rosenthal

Randy Rosenthal teaches writing at Harvard University. He is a graduate of Harvard Divinity School, where he focused on Buddhist Studies, and his work has appeared in The New York Times, The Washington Post, The American Scholar, and many other publications.